---
title: "Comment by Adam Lewis on \"A CLAUDE.md template for beginners (and the rules that actually get followed)\" | Hashnode"
description: "What decided which rules made the cut, and did any of them turn out not to be worth the line?"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/a-claude-md-template-for-beginners-and-the-rules-that-actually-get-followed/6adb5b811e14674ebf37808c/comment/6adc6fc7e881357f4b2b87fc"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/a-claude-md-template-for-beginners-and-the-rules-that-actually-get-followed/6adb5b811e14674ebf37808c)

Comment [A CLAUDE.md template for beginners (and the rules that actually get followed)](https://hashnode.com/posts/a-claude-md-template-for-beginners-and-the-rules-that-actually-get-followed/6adb5b811e14674ebf37808c)

[Adam Lewis](https://hashnode.com/@nark3d)

[Oct 24](https://hashnode.com/posts/a-claude-md-template-for-beginners-and-the-rules-that-actually-get-followed/6adb5b811e14674ebf37808c/comment/6adc6fc7e881357f4b2b87fc)

What decided which rules made the cut, and did any of them turn out not to be worth the line?

[John Banker](https://hashnode.com/@getvibekits)

[Oct 24](https://hashnode.com/posts/a-claude-md-template-for-beginners-and-the-rules-that-actually-get-followed/6adb5b811e14674ebf37808c/comment/6adc6fc7e881357f4b2b87fc#reply-6adcc35e770359afdcc956cb)

A rule stayed only if it changed what the AI actually did across a few real projects. Rules that just repeated what the model already does well, like 'write clean code,' got cut. A short file that gets followed beats a long one that gets skimmed.
