---
title: "Comment by Dov at HireDov on \"Freight rates with error bars: what 100 corridor records look like when uncertainty is a column\" | Hashnode"
description: "Putting an evidence grade next to every figure is the part I wish more freight data did. When I compare a forwarder's quote to a benchmark, the quote is usually"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/freight-rates-with-error-bars/6afbe3f9f97d05ec44bac624/comment/6afcc6ddeabc6e7573e00da1"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/freight-rates-with-error-bars/6afbe3f9f97d05ec44bac624)

Comment [Freight rates with error bars: what 100 corridor records look like when uncertainty is a column](https://hashnode.com/posts/freight-rates-with-error-bars/6afbe3f9f97d05ec44bac624)

[Dov at HireDov](https://hashnode.com/@hiredov)

[12h ago](https://hashnode.com/posts/freight-rates-with-error-bars/6afbe3f9f97d05ec44bac624/comment/6afcc6ddeabc6e7573e00da1)

Putting an evidence grade next to every figure is the part I wish more freight data did. When I compare a forwarder's quote to a benchmark, the quote is usually one confident number and the benchmark a vague range, so the comparison is mostly vibes. A band on both sides makes it obvious when a quote is inside normal noise versus genuinely off. One thing I'd love to see: a flag for what a rate includes (origin charges, surcharges, validity window), since two quotes can look 15% apart purely because of scope. Curious whether the grade reflects how recent the data is, or how many sources agree?

[BtoB-GoGo](https://hashnode.com/@btob-gogo)

[6h ago](https://hashnode.com/posts/freight-rates-with-error-bars/6afbe3f9f97d05ec44bac624/comment/6afcc6ddeabc6e7573e00da1#reply-6afd21f2dfc0fbc6733cc581)

Thank you for reading it closely, and for naming the harder half of the problem: scope.

On the grade. It measures one thing only — how far a figure sits from a published source — and not how recent the data is, nor how many sources agree. W and K are index values for that lane (Drewry WCI, and the KCCI route) at ±10%. D is a published anchor adjusted onto a corridor with no direct quote, at ±25%. S scales an anchor by the SCFI ratio, A converts a TAC air rate to a per-kilogram figure, and M is a model estimate that says so in the column. Recency is carried separately: every row has an as\_of date, currently 2026-11-06 throughout the file, and a correction goes into the next edition rather than being patched in place. Consensus across sources is not encoded yet; we would rather leave a cell empty than present one source as several.

On scope, you are right that it is where two quotes 15% apart usually come from, which is why the benchmark keeps surcharges outside the rate on purpose. Ocean rows are one element of a bill: origin and destination THC, Maersk's EMS ($170/40ft) and ESS ($190/40ft), and PierPass ($40.63/TEU) are published as separate rows with their own source and effective date, so a comparison does not quietly fold them in. A machine-readable inclusions field — origin charges, surcharges, validity window — is the honest next column for this table. It is not in the November edition, and we would rather say so than approximate it.

The corridor file (benchmark-2026-11.csv) downloads free from the data page of this publication's site, and the EU–Asia cut of the same data, gateway by gateway, is the report published here yesterday.

— BtoB-GoGo, published by MMS Consulting Group (엠엠에스컨설팅)
