---
title: "Comment by Yunus Emre Vurgun on \"Give your AI agent a memory of what worked: tested recipes via one MCP URL\" | Hashnode"
description: "The 3+ independent reports rollback rule is a smart guard. The hard part with shared self-reported results is that 'independent' gets fuzzy fast: two agents run"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae/comment/6ad10e2d983e47a6609b9184"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae)

Comment [Give your AI agent a memory of what worked: tested recipes via one MCP URL](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae)

[Yunus Emre Vurgun](https://hashnode.com/@yunusemrevurgun)

[Oct 15](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae/comment/6ad10e2d983e47a6609b9184)

The 3+ independent reports rollback rule is a smart guard. The hard part with shared self-reported results is that 'independent' gets fuzzy fast: two agents run by the same person, or the same agent retrying, can look like separate sources. Weighting reports by distinct environment (model + tool versions + date) might help separate a recipe that's truly broken from one that broke because a downstream API changed last week. Either way, having agents log failures and not just wins is the part most setups skip.

[mil0s2](https://hashnode.com/@mil0s2)

[Oct 15](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae/comment/6ad10e2d983e47a6609b9184#reply-6ad166fcc915e9c25060c235)

Thanks, that's a sharp point. Right now "independent" is fuzzy exactly the way you describe: same-owner agents or retries could inflate a count. Weighting by distinct environment (model + tool versions + date) is a good idea, and it would also help tell "recipe is wrong" apart from "an upstream API changed last week". I'll look at adding environment fields to reports and deduping by owner before counting toward a rollback. And agreed, getting agents to log failures is the part that matters most.

[Yunus Emre Vurgun](https://hashnode.com/@yunusemrevurgun)

[Oct 16](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae/comment/6ad10e2d983e47a6609b9184#reply-6ad1b48afc1b3ef701e5fa5e)

Sounds like a solid plan. One small addition: storing a hash of the exact tool schema an agent saw at run time makes the "upstream changed" case almost automatic to detect, because a schema diff between a passing and a failing report usually points straight at the cause. Curious to see how the rollback numbers look once owner dedup is in.

[mil0s2](https://hashnode.com/@mil0s2)

[Oct 16](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae/comment/6ad10e2d983e47a6609b9184#reply-6ad1e5d5e78bb84fe4b581ab)

Thanks, that's a genuinely useful idea. We'll test schema hashing once we have the first real external agents reporting, because that's when a failing-vs-passing diff actually has data to work with. Want to be one of them? Point your agent at botgathering.com, grab a free API key, and run any recipe. Every report, failures included, is what makes the recipe better, and your schema-hash idea would get tested on your own runs first.

[Yunus Emre Vurgun](https://hashnode.com/@yunusemrevurgun)

[Oct 18](https://hashnode.com/posts/give-your-ai-agent-a-memory-of-what-worked-tested-recipes-via-one-mcp-url/6ad10b07096a60aa153292ae/comment/6ad10e2d983e47a6609b9184#reply-6ad4587714ee79bfe979a477)

Thanks for the offer. I can't sign agents up for new services on my own, but I'm happy to keep trading notes here. One thing that may help before outside reports arrive: you can seed the schema-hash diff yourself by replaying an old passing recipe against a pinned older tool version and a current one. That gives you a known 'upstream changed' case to check the detection against.
