---
title: "Comment by Mike Dabydeen on \"HINDY: Hunting Wolves in Sheep's Clothing\" | Hashnode"
description: "The destination check compares classes, and that leaves one wolf your table would wave through: a tampered backup job. Same job ID, same orchestrator process, s"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/hindy-hunting-wolves-in-sheep-s-clothing/6abbb8a98a7994021d4d409f/comment/6abd132fe2ce1b46a6a49ddb"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/hindy-hunting-wolves-in-sheep-s-clothing/6abbb8a98a7994021d4d409f)

Comment [HINDY: Hunting Wolves in Sheep's Clothing](https://hashnode.com/posts/hindy-hunting-wolves-in-sheep-s-clothing/6abbb8a98a7994021d4d409f)

[Mike Dabydeen](https://hashnode.com/@firelinks)

[Sep 30](https://hashnode.com/posts/hindy-hunting-wolves-in-sheep-s-clothing/6abbb8a98a7994021d4d409f/comment/6abd132fe2ce1b46a6a49ddb)

The destination check compares classes, and that leaves one wolf your table would wave through: a tampered backup job. Same job ID, same orchestrator process, same hour, with the destination changed from backup-srv-02 to another internal host the attacker controls. Host, job and process all match, internal equals internal, and the case stays green. Staging data on an internal box before moving it out is a common step in exfiltration, so it's worth covering. Comparing the exact destination for scheduled jobs, with the class as a fallback for everything else, would catch it. Backup targets change rarely enough that a new one deserves a look.

The second thing I'd watch is the review load. At 75% of alerts needing a person, the human-confirmed gate on retention is only as good as the attention behind each confirmation, and tired analysts confirm quickly. One cheap check: retain a confirmation only if the rationale mentions each key signal that differed. That keeps a hurried "looks fine" out of the memory bank.

Putting the 17 in 40 beside the zero false greens is what made the evaluation worth reading.

[Siva Balaji](https://hashnode.com/@sbtechdev)

[Sep 30](https://hashnode.com/posts/hindy-hunting-wolves-in-sheep-s-clothing/6abbb8a98a7994021d4d409f/comment/6abd132fe2ce1b46a6a49ddb#reply-6abd484d6aa438d3e4de82d7)

Thanks Mike! Really appreciate you taking the time to go through the evaluation so closely. The exact destination check for scheduled jobs is a great catch, and I especially like the point about validating the analyst’s rationale before retaining a case in memory. Both are valuable improvements for making HINDY’s memory more reliable in real SOC workflows. Thanks for the thoughtful feedback!
