---
title: "Comment by Mihai_LeanZero on \"I grew my agent instruction file from 90KB to 147KB. Violations did not drop. The 8 rules I moved into code did.\" | Hashnode"
description: "This is one of the more honest measurement posts I've read on this topic - the selection-bias and reverse-causation objections you raise against your own result"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/i-grew-my-agent-instruction-file-from-90kb-to-147kb-violations-did-not-drop-the-8-rules-i-moved-into-code-did/6ab2cf53e07effab49016b76/comment/6ab2de072b0da52d7af599a8"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/i-grew-my-agent-instruction-file-from-90kb-to-147kb-violations-did-not-drop-the-8-rules-i-moved-into-code-did/6ab2cf53e07effab49016b76)

Comment [I grew my agent instruction file from 90KB to 147KB. Violations did not drop. The 8 rules I moved into code did.](https://hashnode.com/posts/i-grew-my-agent-instruction-file-from-90kb-to-147kb-violations-did-not-drop-the-8-rules-i-moved-into-code-did/6ab2cf53e07effab49016b76)

[Mihai\_LeanZero](https://hashnode.com/@mihaileanzero)

[Sep 22](https://hashnode.com/posts/i-grew-my-agent-instruction-file-from-90kb-to-147kb-violations-did-not-drop-the-8-rules-i-moved-into-code-did/6ab2cf53e07effab49016b76/comment/6ab2de072b0da52d7af599a8)

This is one of the more honest measurement posts I've read on this topic - the selection-bias and reverse-causation objections you raise against your own result are exactly the ones that needed raising, and most people wouldn't have bothered. One thing I'm curious about in the tier-2 design: since the injected top-3 set is chosen dynamically by recent violation count, a newly-written clause for a brand-new rule has to compete for one of those three slots against whatever is currently violating the most. If it doesn't win a slot early, does it get less reinforcement than an established high-violator, and does that change how fast it accumulates the three violations needed to earn a code gate in the first place? That would be a form of selection bias in which rules ever make it into Group A - gated because they violated often enough, fast enough, to win a top-3 slot, not necessarily because they mattered most. Tracking how long a rule waits before first cracking the top 3, separate from the recurrence count you're already logging, might surface that.
