---
title: "Comment by Ahmet Özel on \"Layout-Aware and Hierarchical Chunking Are Stages, Not Strategies\" | Hashnode"
description: "The stages-not-strategies correction is the one I needed a year ago. The listicles compare them because both answer \"how do I split\", but layout-aware runs at p"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/layout-aware-vs-hierarchical-chunking-they-are-not-the-choice-you-think/6a9f56901f625b1e3feba40c/comment/6aa39aeb2918c96918750892"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/layout-aware-vs-hierarchical-chunking-they-are-not-the-choice-you-think/6a9f56901f625b1e3feba40c)

Comment [Layout-Aware and Hierarchical Chunking Are Stages, Not Strategies](https://hashnode.com/posts/layout-aware-vs-hierarchical-chunking-they-are-not-the-choice-you-think/6a9f56901f625b1e3feba40c)

[Ahmet Özel](https://hashnode.com/@ahmetozel)

[Sep 11](https://hashnode.com/posts/layout-aware-vs-hierarchical-chunking-they-are-not-the-choice-you-think/6a9f56901f625b1e3feba40c/comment/6aa39aeb2918c96918750892)

The stages-not-strategies correction is the one I needed a year ago. The listicles compare them because both answer "how do I split", but layout-aware runs at parse time against the physical page and hierarchical runs after you already have a heading tree, so asking which to pick is a category error.

The condition I would move earliest is whether the heading structure is trustworthy. On PDFs where headings are a visual convention rather than tagged structure, hierarchical chunking inherits whatever the parser guessed, and a wrong parent silently attaches a clause to the wrong section. From the outside that looks exactly like a retrieval miss, so you go tune the retriever. I now eyeball the heading tree on a sample before trusting parent-child retrieval at all.
