---
title: "Comment by Andrew on \"My AI Said \"Fixed\" Three Times. It Was Wrong Three Times.\" | Hashnode"
description: "Fixed is a claim about a system you have not re-broken yet. The gate is a second agent that has to reproduce the failure on a clean checkout before any fix land"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/my-ai-said-fixed-three-times-it-was-wrong-three-times/6a7ba4d273a925ad0cde4bbd/comment/6a7c17d6e6b9ce93b852a83a"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/my-ai-said-fixed-three-times-it-was-wrong-three-times/6a7ba4d273a925ad0cde4bbd)

Comment [My AI Said "Fixed" Three Times. It Was Wrong Three Times.](https://hashnode.com/posts/my-ai-said-fixed-three-times-it-was-wrong-three-times/6a7ba4d273a925ad0cde4bbd)

[Andrew](https://hashnode.com/@rizzdev)

[Aug 12](https://hashnode.com/posts/my-ai-said-fixed-three-times-it-was-wrong-three-times/6a7ba4d273a925ad0cde4bbd/comment/6a7c17d6e6b9ce93b852a83a)

Fixed is a claim about a system you have not re-broken yet. The gate is a second agent that has to reproduce the failure on a clean checkout before any fix lands. Wanting to believe the model is the whole problem. I see it fails the merge gate. Less code that clears that bar still wins over three green checkmarks that never saw the original break again.

[Seiji Nakaya](https://hashnode.com/@snakaya)

[Aug 12](https://hashnode.com/posts/my-ai-said-fixed-three-times-it-was-wrong-three-times/6a7ba4d273a925ad0cde4bbd/comment/6a7c17d6e6b9ce93b852a83a#reply-6a7cee22ea4b5fe88f030d88)

Fixed is a claim about a system you have not re-broken yet", I wish I'd written that line.

I didn't adopt the reproduce-first gate as a principle either. I added it after getting burned, because I needed something I couldn't argue our way past. The model being wrong three times was normal. Me accepting it three times is what needed the gate.
