---
title: "Comment by Evelyn Wyatt on \"RAG vs Long Context in .NET\" | Hashnode"
description: "The distinction between finding relevant evidence and preserving sufficient evidence for reasoning is an important one here. A retrieval system can return highl"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/rag-vs-long-context-in-net/6ac12ef77048726fab66cd50/comment/6ac38c67c6334ea27e3bd211"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/rag-vs-long-context-in-net/6ac12ef77048726fab66cd50)

Comment [RAG vs Long Context in .NET](https://hashnode.com/posts/rag-vs-long-context-in-net/6ac12ef77048726fab66cd50)

[Evelyn Wyatt](https://hashnode.com/@Evelynwyatt)

[Oct 5](https://hashnode.com/posts/rag-vs-long-context-in-net/6ac12ef77048726fab66cd50/comment/6ac38c67c6334ea27e3bd211)

The distinction between finding relevant evidence and preserving sufficient evidence for reasoning is an important one here. A retrieval system can return highly relevant chunks and still fail if the answer depends on a definition, exception, or relationship that wasn't included in the final evidence bundle. I’d be interested in evaluating “evidence completeness” alongside retrieval precision and recall: not just whether the expected passage was retrieved, but whether all dependencies required to justify the answer survived selection and packing. That metric could also make the RAG-versus-long-context decision more concrete. If a task repeatedly requires broad evidence relationships, long context or structured parent expansion may be the better baseline even when top-k retrieval looks strong.

[Patrick Kearns](https://hashnode.com/@fullstackcity)

[Oct 6](https://hashnode.com/posts/rag-vs-long-context-in-net/6ac12ef77048726fab66cd50/comment/6ac38c67c6334ea27e3bd211#reply-6ac53d7a9ca5553710ebb889)

Yeah, thats worth measuring alongside precision and recall. Id test completeness against the evidence actually sent to the model, because retrieving a required definition or exception doesn't help if packing drops it. Questions with known evidence dependencies would make a useful comparison between top-k retrieval, parent expansion and long context, checking whether each approach preserves enough evidence to support the answer.
