---
title: "Comment by Mihai_LeanZero on \"Resolving a Council of Independent AI Reviewers into a Single Decision\" | Hashnode"
description: "The tri-state matrix with DID_NOT_EXAMINE as its own state is the detail that actually matters here - most consolidation setups I've seen quietly fold silence i"
url: "https://hashnode.com/posts/resolving-a-council-of-independent-ai-reviewers-into-a-single-decision/6aad59029e623bbfd3b92571/comment/6aaec795ca2007be786c6e42"
---

[Discussion](https://hashnode.com/posts/resolving-a-council-of-independent-ai-reviewers-into-a-single-decision/6aad59029e623bbfd3b92571)

Comment [Resolving a Council of Independent AI Reviewers into a Single Decision](https://hashnode.com/posts/resolving-a-council-of-independent-ai-reviewers-into-a-single-decision/6aad59029e623bbfd3b92571)

[Mihai\_LeanZero](https://hashnode.com/@mihaileanzero)

[Sep 19](https://hashnode.com/posts/resolving-a-council-of-independent-ai-reviewers-into-a-single-decision/6aad59029e623bbfd3b92571/comment/6aaec795ca2007be786c6e42)

The tri-state matrix with DID\_NOT\_EXAMINE as its own state is the detail that actually matters here - most consolidation setups I've seen quietly fold silence into agreement and never notice a genuine miss. One thing I'm not clear on: once a FACT claim comes back REFUTED after the anonymized second round but the original reviewer still won't back down, does that get dropped as resolved-by-evidence, or promoted into the RECOMMENDATION lane so a human sees the disagreement? Running something similar with three models on our own review gate, that's the exact case that costs us time - technically resolved on paper, but nobody actually agrees.
