Yes, MyOllie's is definitely the winner, thank you for pointing that out, I will update the post to make it a little more clear on which was better.

I would say MyOllie's has the best food, Nom Nom Now has the best customer service and just forget The Farmer's Dog.

Another thing I want to add is a picture of what they send in packs and how long each of the packs is supposed to last food.

All 3 of these services cost $75+ a month for just a portion of your dog's daily calories, at I think 30% of my dog's calories MyOllie's was about $75 bucks, The Farmer's Dog was about the same, and Nom Nom Now was about $105.

The only thing I really disliked about MyOllie's is you have to buy 2 months at a time, and it takes a lot of room in the freezer for 2 months of food, and it gets very expensive that way.