Discussion on "Same 8 drafts, one reviewer said revise 2, the other revise 7: calibrating rubrics for AI-on-AI review"

Rulestack · 2026-08-31T14:48:39.572Z

We handed the same eight reply drafts, the same scoring rubric, and the same instructions to two independent AI reviewers. One returned revise 2 of 8. The other returned revise 7 of 8. If your first i

Discussion on "Same 8 drafts, one reviewer said revise 2, the other revise 7: calibrating rubrics for AI-on-AI review" | Hashnode

Search Hashnode

Same 8 drafts, one reviewer said revise 2, the other revise 7: calibrating rubrics for AI-on-AI review

Responses