So, I tried Monaco again, and I feel like that was the font I used before reformat and just didn't realize it. I am currently giving mononoki a chance though! Thanks for all your replies and keep them coming!

Ugh. I really want to use this, can't justify the $200 price point though. :(

My co-worker suggested Fira to me, I'm not a fan of the >= <= ligatures :( Not that I run into those signs too often though.