The way I see it, the internet is like a road system. It's a conduit to enable a user to connect from point a to point b. While it is true that some road systems have tolls and some have fast lanes, there's nothing at all that prevents a slower vehicle from arriving at their destination. Based on things I'm reading, not having net neutrality opens up the way for ISPs to start charging to access specific sites.
For example, you want Netflix and Hulu? Fine, buy package A, which includes both services. But, package B only includes access to Netflix, but you can forget about Hulu.
I don't know about the rest of you, but my monthly internet service is already very expensive. If I have to pay a cover charge just to access specific sites, I would not be happy at all.