The finding that the same split won or lost depending on whether each agent got exact verify commands is a useful isolating result. With six runs per setup, though, the 18 to 61 minute auto-split spread makes me curious whether the win is the frozen plan or the narrower checks, since your own plan also carried the exact commands. A fourth arm with a frozen plan but the original loose VERIFY line, or the auto-split given your narrow-check template, would separate those two effects.