Thanks, that's a good way to frame it. I'd keep the paid entitlement and the moderation decision as two separate states. A successful renewal can extend the paid period without automatically restoring group access. Re-admission should require both a valid entitlement and no active moderation restriction. There's also an important distinction with idempotency: deduplicating webhook events isn't always enough if multiple events refer to the same underlying payment. The payment itself needs a stable identifier. One question I'd be interested in exploring: if someone renews while still banned, would you keep the subscription period running or pause it until the moderation issue is resolved?
