The step I'd add is writing the rule down before the next outage, as a short table you can paste into a macro. Something like: not active during the window = apology plus what changed, no money; lost part of a working day = credit of about a quarter month; failed job or missed deadline = refund of that month, or a bigger credit if they want to stay. Then check each ticket against the same three questions: were they active in the window, did anything fail for them specifically, and are they already cancelling? Log the answer and the amount in the ticket so the second customer gets the same outcome as the first. One more point: with annual plans, a credit can sit unseen for eleven months, so offer a refund or an extension of the term instead. Reply the same day, even if it's only to say you're checking their account.