Useful write-up. The point about the management layer being the weak spot is the part most site owners miss.
Full disclosure: I work at Cloudways. Even though we store server backups off-site by default and let users download them, I still recommend keeping an independent copy in an account you control; that is what saves you if the provider itself goes down. As you mentioned, a backup you have never tested is just a guess.
Thanks Ali, and thanks for the disclosure. Agreed, the independent copy in an account you control is the part people skip until they need it. I'd add one step: restore it to a staging site now and then, not just download it.
Disclosure on my side: I'm with HackerMe (hackerme.ai), a free outside-in website scanner. We often see the opposite backup problem there: a backup.zip or SQL dump left on a public URL, where anyone can download it.
Ali Asghar Jamil
Useful write-up. The point about the management layer being the weak spot is the part most site owners miss.
Full disclosure: I work at Cloudways. Even though we store server backups off-site by default and let users download them, I still recommend keeping an independent copy in an account you control; that is what saves you if the provider itself goes down. As you mentioned, a backup you have never tested is just a guess.